Stay at E.B. Morgan House, a refined waterfront hotel in Aurora, NY offering free Wi-Fi, breakfast, spa, and easy access to Finger Lakes wineries and parks.
Guests appreciate the elegant setting, attentive service, and scenic waterfront views, while noting the limited dining options nearby. This refined hotel suits travelers seeking a peaceful and historic getaway in the heart of a charming lakeside village.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Situated on the shores of Cayuga Lake, E.B. Morgan House occupies a historic waterfront mansion that blends period-accurate renovations with modern comforts. Guests can expect an elegant setting featuring opulent décor and well-appointed rooms that combine sophistication with contemporary touches. Many reviewers highlight the property's unique charm and relaxing lakeside atmosphere.
Facilities include free Wi-Fi, complimentary breakfast, and on-site parking, making stays convenient for visitors. The hotel also offers a restaurant, spa, and fitness center, allowing guests to unwind without leaving the premises. Accessibility features and a smoke-free environment contribute to a comfortable experience, though the property does not accommodate pets.
Located at 431 Main St in Aurora, NY, the hotel is just a short walk from local wineries and state parks, providing opportunities for leisurely exploration. Notable nearby attractions include Buttonwood Grove Winery and the Women's Rights National Historical Park. The proximity to airports such as Ithaca Tompkins International Airport (approximately 34 minutes by car) adds to the convenience for travelers.
The venue also serves as a wedding location, praised for its beautiful dining spaces and attentive staff. While some guests note the rooms could be larger and cuisine options in the surrounding area are limited, overall feedback reflects a positive stay with attentive service and a peaceful lakeside retreat.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
Highly recommended place to go if you need to unwind. I am from NYC and was looking for a weekend getaway with my partner. Before I even arrived, Brittany texted me to let me know my room was ready and if there was anything I needed. Upon arrival, she gave us a wonderful tour and assisted us with anything we needed throughout our entire stay. Brittany was also great with recommendations on different things to do as it was our first time at the village. The rooms are very nice, have a chic style to them but also combined with modernization. I do wish they were slightly larger but everything was very clean and organized. The actual inn is super unique and just pleasing to walk through. Waking up to having a coffee by the lake was the peace and quiet I did not think I needed, but will definitely be back for more. My overall first time experience was great. Was it a bit pricey? Yes it was. Did I have a good time and relaxed? Also yes. I think for the value of everything, its worth checking out and seeing something new and generally not common to come across such a great village. The only thing I really hoped for was more food options. The food at the local bar/grill and the 1833 are very good. We just simply found ourselves going to the same places because the options are so limited. Maybe future business owners will create other cuisine options.
We went this past weekend for my sister in law's wedding. They could not have picked a nicer location! The inn is stunningly beautiful with lovely rooms and cozy and inviting common areas... including a library! The dining room was beautiful and ideal for the wedding dinner. Catering was fantastic, and Maddy is the best innkeeper! Thank you for a wonderful weekend!
This opulent home from 1830's affluence on Cayuga Lake sent me down a wormhole, Googling wallpaper history and confirming that this resort was painstakingly renovated in period-correct detail with modern amenities in bath and kitchen that was the perfect backdrop to celebrate our 33rd wedding anniversary. Highly recommend!
Had a wonderful stay. Beautiful location with breathtaking views
Absolutely beautiful place on a beautiful Lake.. Fantastic service.. Impeccably clean... Excellent food at associated restaurants
Great place to visit and relax. Lovely house and country side is beautiful.
Stunning historic getaway in Aurora! We absolutely loved our stay at this beautiful private residence. Gorgeous rooms with lovely amenities. Next time, we plan to stay longer! Many thanks to Judy for a wonderful experience!
I booked the whole place for my wedding weekend and it was beautiful. Judy was our grounds keeper and she was absolutely lovely, and so incredibly helpful. Thank you, Judy!!
On the shores of Cayuga lake, this refined town-center stone hotel with an elegant porch overlooks the water and is 3 miles from Finger Lakes at Long Point State Park and a 3-minute walk from Bet the Farm Winery.
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in New York. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
403 reviews 5986 NY-89, Romulus, NY 14541, United States
1,249 reviews 136 Fall St, Seneca Falls, NY 13148, United States
587 reviews 6861 NY-89, Ovid, NY 14521, United States
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Stay at Crown Choice Inn & Suites Lakeview Waterpark in Mackinaw City, featuring free WiFi, water park access, indoor/outdoor poo...
Relax at Holiday Inn Express & Suites Omaha Airport with free breakfast, indoor pool, gym, and convenient access to Eppley Airfiel...
Stay at The Setai, Miami Beach with teak suites, 3 pools, spa, and beach access near Lincoln Road & botanical gardens. Rated 4.6 f...
Stay at MainStay Suites Bismarck, a 4.1star extended stay hotel offering free breakfast, pool, and shuttle. Close to Dakota Zoo, ...
Stay at The Stiles Hotel in Miami Beach featuring retrochic rooms, 3 plunge pools, free WiFi, and easy access to Ocean Drive nig...
Simple hotel near Bromley Mountain Ski Resort offering mountain views, outdoor pool, hot tub, and LGBTQ+ friendly lodging in Manch...
Stay at Frame Hotel SoCo, rated 4.9 with 51 reviews. Enjoy a trendy Austin location near Barton Springs Pool, Texas Capitol, and...
Stay at Hotel West Inn Hollywood in Los Angeles offering free WiFi, parking, and airport shuttle. Close to TCL Chinese Theatre, W...
Affordable rooms with free WiFi, breakfast, and parking near Armstrong Air & Space Museum. Rated 3.8/5 with 189 reviews in Wapako...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
